THE ISSUE: A new report from SVT, Sweden’s public broadcaster, has revealed the the religious leaders in nine of fifteen mosques facilitate polygamy and, in some cases, advise families to stay away from Jews and Swedish society at large.
WHY IT MATTERS: Sweden is one of the most open societies in the West with strong legal protection for religious freedom. What happens, then, if religious authorities promote practices in conflict with Swedish law and social norms? Swedish law does not recognize polygamous marriage and, in fact, provides criminal and civil penalties for those that practice it. These religious leaders and those they advise cannot be allowed to encourage, facilitate, or otherwise make polygamous marriage possible. This cannot be shielded by Sweden’s law guaranteeing religious liberty. Polygamy is a threat to women and families.
THE BACKGROUND: SVT’s Uppdrag granskning aired the results of an investigation into the nature of advice related to marriage and social integration that Islamic leaders were providing to those in their mosques. SVT reporters approached religious leaders in fifteen mosques. They posed as married men looking for additional wives. In nine of the mosques, they were offered assistance. In six mosques, their requests were rejected. In one mosque in Halmstad, the undercover investigator received advice on ways to keep his wife and children from interacting with Swedes and Jews.
DRIVING FORCES: The national debate in Sweden surrounding immigration has focused on the intersection of religious practices, Swedish law, and civic institutions. Sweden Democrats have long insisted that those entering into Sweden must accept Swedish law as supreme and Swedish social customs as obligatory. Integration is impossible when the religious leaders subvert both and encourage others to do the same as they keep their communities isolated.
Even more concerning is the fact that several religious organizations that receive government funding are connected to the nine mosques. All public funds come with an obligation to respect the fundamental rights of all people and the democratic values that mark Swedish society. Fortunately, the appropriate government office in Sweden has opened an inquiry into these organizations.
FAULT LINE: Conservatives across Europe are critical of multiculturalism and doubtful that such an approach can ever work. There has been almost no evidence to prove them wrong. We cannot allow there to be parallel systems of laws and customs especially when these parallel systems undermine the rights of women and girls. Those who believe that multiculturalism can succeed against all available evidence often defend it on the grounds of religious freedom.
The American jurist and Nuremburg prosecutor Robert Jackson is famous for having said that the American Constitution with all of its protections for individual rights is “not a suicide pact.” What is true for the Americans is true for every free nation in the world. Religious freedom cannot be the political conduit through which those who resist integration into Swedish society are allowed to ignore our laws and undermine our social mores.
THE OVERLOOKED FACTOR: It is easy to see these reports and be filled with frustration by the blatant disregard for Swedish law. But we also need to recognize that “second wives” in religious communities always lack legal protections afforded to women who enjoy legal status as a wife. Theoretically the state will protect second wives from violence, but she remains completely vulnerable if her husband decides to end the religious marriage. There is no law that entitles her to property, resources, or any of the other things afforded parties in a proper divorce proceeding. No matter the complexities, if these second wives are Swedish citizens then they are entitled to the full protection of Swedish law and no religious law can supersede that.
LOOKING AHEAD: The fact that there is still no new government in Sweden complicates the government’s response, although some government investigations have begun. Government actors must not cower in fear as they are intimidated by these institutions. They must scrutinize the use of government funds and the use of government records to make sure that these groups do no more damage to Sweden’s laws and society.
THE BROADER LESSON: Polygamy is banned even in Turkey, which for decades also punished clerics who performed religious marriages outside the law. If a Muslim-majority country could draw that line, so can Sweden. Religious freedom protects the right to believe and to worship. It has never protected the right to place a second wife outside the law, or to raise children apart from the society they live in. Integration does not begin when newcomers learn the language. It begins when everyone, including those who lead congregations, accepts that Swedish law comes first. The task now is simple to state, if not to carry out: make Swedish law apply fully, in every congregation, and stop funding those who refuse.



