MY TAKE
The European Union’s criminal jurisdiction only extends to cross-border, international issues like terrorism, human trafficking, and organized crime. Hate speech, does not rise to that level of significance and the EU must end its attempt to regulate, investigate, and punish hate speech at the European level.
WHAT'S AT STAKE
Freedom of speech is a fundamental right that protects citizens against their governments. It is not a privilege that any government or politician gives, so neither can they take it away. The EU, however, wants to expand its own authority to regulate speech and put hate speech in the same category of serious crimes with terrorism and human trafficking. If enacted, the proposal would place significant influence over the shape of public debate in the hands of unelected bureaucrats.
In 2021, the European Commission proposed “extending the list of EU crimes to hate speech and hate crime.” Then in January 2024, the European Parliament endorsed the idea by a fairly wide margin. To be clear, moving this forward would not create a new law at the European level, per se. This proposal and resolution are in reference to the EU’s Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which allows the EU to set minimum criminal law standards when the crimes in question have a clear cross-border dimension. The criminal codes of member states must meet those minimum standards, according to the treaty. It makes some sense to harmonize laws relating to terrorism, which is a threat to all of us, and to human trafficking so that trafficking rings can’t merely move their operations to avoid the authorities.
The crimes already on the list of the EU’s serious, cross-border crimes–terrorism, human trafficking, and organized crime–are easily identifiable and defined. Hate speech, however, has always been a problematic legal category. There are some who believe that criticizing immigration policies or merely challenging religious beliefs constitutes hatred. And it has never been clear to me why a crime is somehow more serious because of the specific motive of the criminal. Yes, there are those who use their right to free speech to incite violence. That cannot be tolerated, but all member states have laws that address this. It is unclear what a European-level mandate would offer other than an open door for future regulations on speech to be forced upon national governments.
Supporters of these measures argue that these measures are necessary to combat antisemitism and various forms of extremism. National governments clearly have a responsibility to confront these threats, but the laws already on the books against violence, incitement, criminal threats, etc. already provide the tools necessary to do so. Cross-border communication relating to these crimes should not immediately trigger an EU-level response. One of the values that guides the actions of the EU is subsidiarity, which requires that final authority for these types of determinations remain in the hands of national governments unless EU action is clearly necessary. In this case, European action would be detrimental to the speech rights of European citizens.
To move forward, the Council of the European Union would have to unanimously pass such a proposal that would then be approved by the European Parliament. The requirement of unanimity is an important safeguard to the expansion of EU authority. Member states should oppose this expansion of authority and enforce existing national laws instead. We don’t need another transfer of political power from member state legislatures that are democratically elected to EU institutions that are quite distant from democratic accountability.
The Commission has now announced in its 2027 work programme that it intends to withdraw the proposal. That is a welcome signal, but it does not end the underlying pressure. The idea remains popular in parts of the Parliament and among many national governments. The same arguments will return in another form unless member states make clear that speech regulation stays a national competence.
ONE LAST THING
The right to free expression must extend beyond the opinions that are fashionable. We must preserve the rights of citizens to disagree, criticize, and debate. Giving Brussels more authority to determine which ideas and perspectives are welcome in the public square will only erode our democracies. Governments exist to defend the rights of citizens including freedom of expression, and this proposal would have the opposite effect. Conservatives cannot allow Brussels the power to stifle free expression and this proposal would do just that.



